Сравнение мультиплатформенных игр

dimm · 15 Окт 2022

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OyRYhlKPo1I

new lighting, fog, cloth physics, particles, etc

lots of new ToD changes

most textures and materials are similar as OW1

reflective materials are more prominent, added smoke effects

largely art driven changes

character textures, hair rendering are much improved

old costumes are still available

HDR on xbox, playstation, and pc

3 modes on PS5/Series X

resolution

2880x2160 to 3840x2160

60fps, 30fps menus

rare drops in replays and rare screen tearing

balanced

prioritizes 60fps

2560x1440p

character selection and menus run at 60fps

pretty pointless

frame rate

prioritize 120fps

1920x1440 to 2560x1440

vrr supported

stable 120fps

Series S

resolution: 2112x1440p to 2560x1440 / 60fps

balanced: 1920x1080 / 60fps

frame rate: 1408x1080 to 1920x1080 / 120fps

lacking in AO in areas

Switch

docked: 1152x900 to 1600x900 / 30fps

handheld: dynamic 720p / 30fps

lacks SSR, AO, lower texture quality

suffers sub-30fps drops every now and then

shows the engine's scalability well

dimm · 20 Окт 2022

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z6Vno8r4cN8

characters glow in the environment due to them not being affected by GI

AO is lackluster

misaligned specular highlights

feels like a generic open world city rather than "batman"

rain effect is very lacking

lacking atmospheric effects

interiors look much better from an art and design standpoint

interior detail is really good, if last gen

character modeling is very high quality

against Arkham Knight, it's very less dense

Gotham Knights has very few pedestrian NPCs

AK has stormy, foamy tessellated water, GK doesn't come close

GK has better texture work

GK has good TAA, while AK predates TAA

GK hs reduced motion blur compared to AK

PS5/SX - 2160p

high quality ray traced reflections, even on water

SSR on top of RTR

SS - 1440p

SSR and cubemaps

maybe dynamic

UI is larger on PS5

interior cubemaps are different between Xbox and PS5

driving around the city is unstable, as low as 25fps

on foot, similar drops

interior spaces are better, but still has drops

on Series X, train stations cause bigger drops to performance; not on PS5 or Series S

loading is lengthy at 20 seconds between areas

dimm · 25 Окт 2022

RT exclusive to PC

5000 rats in the prequel, 300K rats in this game

capped at 30fps on 60hz displays, 40fps on 120hz displays

pc version has a bugged camera where the camera has stutter

levels are much more open compared to the prequel

farther draw distance, better materials, object density, higher res skybox, larger number of npcs

character models are much more detailed

PS5/SX

native 1440p, reconstructed to 2160p

SS

native 900p

lower quality AO, less dense foliage at range

occasional screen tearing and dips

SX has the most consistent performance

PS5 can drop to mid 20s where SX is stable, majority 30fps

SS is more consistent than PS5

40fps mode has the same settings

SX is more consistent

heavy scenes drop to the mid 30s

PS5 drops further (to 20s at times) and has vsync, so no tearing

SS sits inbetween SX and PS5 again

dimm · 10 Ноя 2022

Батя 2022:

Build for PS4 so not very compromised vs PS5

TAAU chosen over Checker Boarding

PS4 30fps mode feels smooth due to enhanced Motion Blur

Base: Res 1080p@30 stable

Pro: Res 1440p-1656p @30-Perfect (TAAU) in stills close to PS5. Performance 1080p-1656p @~40-50 (heavily leans 1080p most times), no VRR thus jittery.

PS5 graphics are more additional and subtle

- Indirect lighting including use of SSDO (Screen Space Directional Occlusion)

- Greater Shadow Quality on PS5 Quality Mode

- Cinematics include additional lighting (Not Hero Lighting)

- Better quality screen space reflection, enhancing cube maps

- DoF and Motion Blur tied together on RES Mode, separate in Quality Mode

Loading:

Saves PS4 ~30 sec, PS5 10 sec.

Deaths PS4 ~10 sec

Impressively polished and bug free

dimm · 16 Ноя 2022

ray-tracing update still isn't out

2070 super at max settings, dlss performance at 4K is just over 30fps

nov 9th patch intends to improve performance on all systems

scenes that shown dips shows massive improvements

xbox series x still runs better than ps5

optimized settings (2070 Super)

draw distance - medium

console uses custom settings

config can match console

shadow maps - medium

dof/motion blur - medium

volumetric lights - medium

contact shadows - no real performance difference

ambient occlusion - medium

screen space reflections - medium

texture quality - ultra

29% performance uplift over ultra at 1440p/quality dlss

with exactly console settings, vs ps5

5700 - 78%

2060S - 86.5%

2070S - 103.8%

Series X - 123%

2080Ti - 146.7%

6800XT - 173.1%

3080 - 188.4%

4090 - 372.8%

4090 / FG - 500%

xbox scales with bandwidth vs ps5

60fps is theoretically possible on consoles at 1080p

CPU limits are hit, as crowded scenes drop under 60fps

game is will multithread, *coughunlikegothamknightscough*

no #stutterstruggle, game seems to be compiled while booting

camera stutter however when vsync is on, but only the RTX 4000 cards

no FSR 2.0, inhouse TAAU

dimm · 20 Ноя 2022

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CSiPlC-8MFE

XB1 can go down as low as 30-40fps at 900p.
PS4 though, is super optimized. 1080p and locked to 60fps most of the time.

dimm · 2 Дек 2022

Калистый протокол от DF. Игра выглядит круто, но серийным боксам и писи нужон патч, может решат в Day Zero патче:

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Psetdjz01mI

made with UE4.27, the final version of the engine

lots of performance and motion capture

highly fidelity character rendering

in-game model is nearly as detailed as cinematics

environments are equally high quality

high quality motion blur, recommended to keep on

deformable snow and volumetric fog

most lights cast a dynamic shadow in quality mode

animation is exceptional

quality mode use RT reflections and hybrid RT shadows, and ray traced transmission

reflections are used on rough surfaces, which is pretty expensive

gloriously reflective toilets

lots of reflective surfaces in the game

lots of shadow casters

custom work done to UE4

RT shadows can dramatically change the mood of the game

PS5/Series X

quality and performance mode

volumetrics are lower res in performance

1440p-1728p

Series s

not mode options

no RT

1080p

lower res textures and no subsurface scattering

has some bugs

Series X has broken RT reflections and broken fog

DF sent this to the team

performance mode

some inconsistencies, but largely stable, especially with vrr

some scenes can drop to the 50s, might be cpu related

quality mode

series x has lots of drops, devs say a day zero patch would fix this

some areas still have drops

ps5 is more stable, doesn't have too many drops

all platforms has some loading drops

series s is a fairly stable save for some loading drops

PC

#stutterstruggle, no pre-compile option

400ms stutter on an i9 13-series, 700ms stutter on 3600

in-game, you can't change settings other than resolution

very cpu limited, poor utilization

RT drops frame rate by 50% but cpu utilization is very low on a 3600

loading

loading a save is ~5s

SDR

three settings, use srgb if on an OLED

audio quality is superb

great positional audio for surround sound

dimm · 6 Дек 2022

Ведьмак 3 с патчем:

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uhvWrLbk0FI

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ieLbOS0ExQU

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7pWykIsXp6k

Ну и DF тут проанализировала:

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Nzs-__nlTo

dimm · 8 Дек 2022

Dead Space:

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BURokW7aV4I

dimm · 10 Дек 2022

Fornite хоть уже на UE5, но четвертая глава на соответствующем железе поддерживает Lumen/Nanite для освещения/геометрии

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O6GC8TZbJmI

Fortnite already ran in UE5, but chapter 4 introduces lumen, nanite, TSR, and virtual shadowmaps

lumen adds RT reflections and global illumination

the consoles are using software lumen, which is based on distance field meshes

the matrix uses hardware lumen for triangle meshes and better reflections

60fps more uses lumen and nanite, 120fps does not

massive difference in visuals comparing the 60fps and 120fps mode

the rays per pixel is1/16th resolution to achieve 60fps

this causes boiling as light temporally converges to a final frame

nanite enables very high resolution meshes

UE5.1 supports alpha masked textures

but Fortnite does not use this, the leaves and grass are all triangles

meshes had to be remodeled to take advantage of nanite

lod transitions are practically not visible

due to the high quality meshes, the rendering distance for the full meshes is finite, despite nanite's promises

there's a pop-in line in the distance where low res meshes transitions to nanite meshes

temporal super resolution replaced taau, is akin to fsr2

tsr produces a very clean image

virtual shadow maps produces high quality shadows in near field and far field shadows

blades of grass and pebbles cast shadows

vsm isn't cheap and has a visible noise up close

Series S has reduced fidelity because of it

premium systems

no difference in visual settings

4K output, 864p - 1836p internally

average ps5: 55% of 4k, sx: 59% of 4k

reflections are lumen + ssr

series s

540p - 1080p

average 73% of 1080p

glossy reflections are gone, SSR instead

small objects are excluded from the virtual shadow maps

lighting fidelity is reduced

more light leakages, less bounced lighting coverage

pc

has hardware accelerated ray tracing option

reflections are more accurate, character models are in reflections

more accurate shadows

distant objects have better GI

moving objects contribute to GI

less light leaking

some weirdness like some areas has light leaking that SWRT doesn't have

no translucent reflections like the matrix, due to performance

surface cache issues, moving objects are black in reflections

performance

practically locked 60fps on all consoles

pc

shader compilation stutter

is using async shader compilation with shader comp in the menu

not good for a competitive

still better than before, if you can believe that

VP of engineering says the system is still imperfect

characters are streamed in differently

you can outpace world streaming with a vehicle, which can cause stutter

solutions are being looked at for future update

fortnite shows that lumen can be leveraged for more stylistic games without a significant increase in work

dimm · 17 Дек 2022

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pFHpN0wRQlc

PS4

2v2 and airplane drop are 60fps

parachuting and gameplay is 40-60fps, at 30s at time

rarely hits 60fps

540p-1080p, temporally upsampled

texture pop-in

draw distance and resolution might put players at a disadvantage

XBO

450p-900p, temporally upsampled

identical to ps4 settings

audio cuts out for a few seconds

10fps lower than ps4

30-50fps

screen tearing at the top of the screen

2v2 doesn't always hit 60fps

input latency is very noticeable

jaguar is working hella hard

PS4P

best frame rate

50-60fps

1536x1512 to 2688x1512 (horizontal scaling) temporally upsampled

One X

tearing like all the xboxs

1080p-2160p, temporally upsampled

frame rate gets lower than ps4

premium last gen has better grass draw, 1m better

FoV affects frame rate based on what you're looking at

premium systems are below the Series S, though Series S has poorer IQ due to resolution

dimm · 22 Янв 2023

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xSdLX_32UZE

literally the pc graphics menu on console

performance settings controls all of these

all three run at 60fps unless you set your tv to 120hz, then all run at 120fps*

no DRS

default

3840x2160 internally

image quality: 100%

high res textures: on

texture filtering: high

AO: on

shadow quality: medium

foliage sway: on

targets 60fps

performance

2016x1134 internally

image quality: 70%

high res textures: off

texture filtering: low

AO: off

shadow quality: low

foliage sway: off

doesn't hit 120fps despite aiming for that

graphics

4800x2700 internally

image quality: 125%

high res textures: on

texture filtering: high

AO: on

shadow quality: high

foliage sway: on

not always locked at 60fps

enemies update at full framerate

Series S

same as other systems save for resolution

performance mode - 1344x756

default - 2560x1440

graphics - 2560x1440

pixel counting is coming out the same for some reason

new ports are effectively the same as Switch, just higher quality textures, resolution, and frame rate

125% or high shadows will not lock you to 60fps

motion blur affects frame rate

performance mode is overkill for 60fps

default is a locked 60fps on all systems

graphics mode starts faltering from 60fps, ps5 is the best

good with a vrr display

series S is 40-50fps

120fps mode is pretty locked on ps5

Series falls under 120fps, ~115fps

some headroom to bump up some settings

120fps mode on default or graphics mode

ps5 has an advantage vs series x, 7-8fps margin

loading is extremely rapid

dimm · 28 Янв 2023

- Quality mode improves volumetric lighting, ambient occlusion, shadows and some post-processing effects on PS5/XSX. However, these changes are hardly noticeable.
- PC features better textures, anisotropic filtering, shadows and volumetric effects. In any case, the consoles are equivalent to the high PC settings.
- PC Ray-Tracing and PS5/XSX quality modes add a more accurate ambient occlusion of certain elements. Reflections and shadows do not have Ray-Tracing in any version.
- Xbox Series S does not have Ray-Tracing and has some cutbacks in lighting, textures and shadows.
- PS5 has a more aggressive VRS, causing more noticeable artifacts compared to Xbox Series X (minute 2:33).
- Dead Space Remake has one of the best lighting and sound systems I've ever seen. The fact that there is virtually no baked lighting is impressive (and tremendously demanding).
- PS5 has slightly slower load times relative to Xbox Series, though monorail rides last just as long.
- Overall, it's a solid job on all platforms, but Motive's decisions around lighting among other post-processing effects I believe are to blame for the lower resolution on consoles.

Quality Mode: 1440p/30 FPS on SX|PS5 and dynamic 1440p with drops on SS
Performance mode: 2048 x 1080p on SX|PS5

dimm · 31 Янв 2023

Dead Space R:

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JpqAAOgUrCg

original game was built on the Tiger Woods PGA Tour engine

original actually ran well on both 360 and ps3, which was rare

fully streamed environments wasn't a feature of the Frostbite engine, so they had to make changes to the tools to make it work

will benefit future Frostbite game

original environment was physically implausible for seemless design

one area that's reused in two chapters are actually two different maps. in the remake, the area is now one map, dressed differently between the two chapters

intensity director is built into the level streaming system

by tracking player position and camera, any combination of necromorph events can spawn

geometric complexity has massively improved

loose objects have physics and can be interacted with

volumetric fog over the original's billboards

light beams accurately interact with glass surfaces

particles interact with the environment and characters

extensive use of surround sound and deep bass

sound propagates throughout the environment realistically

sound respects the physical properties of the object it's bouncing off of

every light casts a shadow

console quality mode and pc has RT AO

not a major change, but fills out the image well

resolution

performance mode - 1440p with fsr2

quality mode - 2160p with fsr2

dynamic res on both

variable rate shading being used on all systems

on ps5, a software solution is used, it's very messy

a patch is being worked on for consoles and pc

Oliver will be doing a performance video later

many areas are significantly larger with changes to the design

not on par, visually, with Callisto Protocol, but very good

dimm · 5 Фев 2023

View: https://youtu.be/ZxuFc0VkxEw

dimm · 5 Фев 2023

View: https://youtu.be/8qppoWhanwk

dimm · 7 Фев 2023

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T8qJKfYswrE

dimm · 9 Фев 2023

Dead Space PC:

menus run at 30fps

a game restart is needed for settings to properly take

has pre-game compilation and quick

the quickness might make it incomplete

deleting cache doesn't restart pre-compilation

some scenes can run worse on the same hardware for no reason

lots of traversal/streaming stutter

if there are lots of doors, expect lots of loading stutter

stutter is worse on weaker hardware

consoles have this same stutter but lessened and differently

DLSS 2.5/FSR 2.1.2/TAA

fsr has ghosting on particles and in-world UI

taa has higher texture quality

texture bias errors, can be fixed via nvidia inspector

can cause menu flickering

optimized settings

VRS off, has a performance degradation when using reconstruction

DRS on, up to 17% of the internal resolution

with performance mode fsr/dlss, reconstruction won't take effect much

lighting setting all look and perform the same; use anything but low

reflection - high or ultra

shadows - medium

volumetric quality - medium

AO - for 2060S super, SSAO; for higher, RTAO

DoF - user choice

VRAM issues

the game seems to randomly fill vram; doesn't matter with ram amount

some cutscenes fill the vram, causing spillover

if this is happening, turning off RT or lowering output resolution

ReBar

on nvidia, you have to add the game manually

1%-4% increase on cpu limited sequences

dimm · 17 Фев 2023

shader precompilation

35 secs on a 3600, 6 seconds on a 12900K

works somewhat decently

the benchmark may be more heavy than the game

pc settings are Chad Warden approved

has all the upscalers except FSR2

FSR2 and DLSS3 coming soon

there's a spatial upscaler than you can turn off in the ini

non-21:9 ultrawides have border issues

ps5 is native 1080p, temporally upscales to 1440p, then checkerboarded to 2160p

not very good

UE4's TAAU breaks depth of field

ps5 will always look different because the system handles tonemapping differently

0% contrast on PC makes it more like PS5

RT reflections mainly affects water, makes it very visible compared to ps5

lighting in RT reflections might not align with the world

RT Shadows is good but limited thanks to a lot of baked shadows

dynamic objects' shadows don't move when RT shadows is on

base UE4 problem, Nvidia's custom UE4 branch fixes this, but Returnal wasn't made on it

volumetrics are much higher res

optimized settings (for a 2060S)

RT reflections - off

greatly enhances the look but has frame time issues

RT shadows - off

can run better than shadowmaps at time

volumetric fog - high

AO - medium

model quality - epic

particle quality - high

shadow quality - high

lighting quality - epic

texture quality - epic for 8GB gpus

variable rate shading (for amd users) - on, but has some flickering

dynamic resolution scaling (for amd users) - does not work with vsync on or external cappers

audio - RT off

causes some frame time issues

stutter struggle

traversal stutter thanks to loading

higher end cpu and no RT minimizes hitching

mid range cpu and no rt can have 50ms spikes

RT shadows, reflections, and audio causes frequent, heavy spikes

geometry mesh creation causes stutters

a patch is being made to fix this

dimm · 24 Фев 2023

Пока Atomic лучше на PS5 из консолей:

View: https://youtu.be/R3BjBLVAYgY

PS5 и Xbox Series X|S используют временное сглаживание Unreal Engine TAA с хорошими результатами, и оба используют практически одинаковые характеристики с точки зрения используемых технологий и графических решений. Вместо этого Xbox Series S отображает игру в разрешении 1080p, в этом случае также динамично, но почти постоянно стабильно при этом значении.

Разницу между PS5 и Xbox Series X можно увидеть, прежде всего, с точки зрения производительности, учитывая, что версия для PS5 более жестко привязана к 60 кадрам в секунду, в то время как версия для Xbox фиксирует некоторые падения, даже существенные в некоторых ситуациях, с неравномерностями, которые кажутся происходят в основном из-за запуска патча первого дня, который, похоже, внес некоторые сбои и ошибки на консолях Microsoft.

Версия для ПК является лучшей с точки зрения качества графики и стабильности производительности, хотя при запуске в ней отсутствует трассировка лучей, о чем уже сообщалось ранее. Игра поддерживает DLSS2 с генерацией кадров из DLSS3, а также FSR 1.0. Между тем, Mundfish уже сообщила, что в предстоящих патчах будут представлены более крупные субтитры и настройка FOV, а также, вероятно, исправлены ошибки и еще больше улучшится производительность.

Сравнение мультиплатформенных игр

Похожие темы