Сравнение мультиплатформенных игр

Hi-Fi Rush на PS5 лучше чем на боксе))


PS5 and Series X versions are identical in performance and visuals except for shadow quality curiously, which is at a higher settings quality on PS5 than even the maxed PC shadows setting. Supposedly Series X and PC are both set to the max setting of 5 for shadow quality on Unreal Engine, so it seems like some sort of bug on the PC/Xbox version. They also retested Pentiment on Series X post 120 patch, both consoles now operate at 120 fps with similar small dips in performance. Except for the opening scene, which shows a significant performance difference in favour of Series X. Tom also goes on to state how important it is for MS to ensure issues like these are caught in QA going forward, given the contentiousness around these first party ports to rival platforms. They also go over differences we have seen between platforms across the generation so far.
Нажмите, чтобы раскрыть...
 
Море воров на PS5:

 
Тцушима:

 
Xbox Series S vs Xbox One X


Diablo 4
864p internally paired with FSR2 for a "1440p-like resolve" for both consoles
Simplified terrain on One X
Image quality is a match otherwise
One X is 30fps with traversal stutters
Series S is "largely smooth 60fps" without traversal stutters
10.06 seconds to load in on Series S, 33.73 seconds on One X

Assassin's Creed Mirage
One X is 1728p on average, Series S is dynamic 1080p
One X has reduced texture quality, texture assets, simplified lighting and lower foliage resolution
One X also has higher shadow resolution
One X is 30fps, "generally comes in at 30"
Series S is 60fps "the vast majority of the time"
30 fps cutscenes on both systems
11.16 seconds to load in on Series S, 34.87 seconds for One X

Persona 3 Reload
One X is 1440p, Series S is 1080p
One X has a close to locked 30fps with bad framepacing making it feel jerky
Series S has a completely locked 60fps with perfect framepacing
Both consoles lack raytraced features
Visual settings are the same on both
01.62 seconds to load in on Series S, 04.15 seconds on One X

Like a Dragon: Ishin
Both consoles have similar visual settings @ 1080p
One X has "near constant frame-pacing problems" at 30fps
Series S is a mostly stable 60fps
Ambient occlusion is slightly stronger on Series S
07.56 seconds to load in on Series S, 23.77 seconds to load in on One X

Like a Dragon: Infinite Wealth
One X is 1080p, Series S is 720p (but Series S has FSR2)
One X has a steady, properly framepaced 30fps
Series S is 60fps with "little framerate dips"
05.74 seconds to load in on Series S, 33.45 seconds for One X

Wo Long: Fallen Dynasty
One X is 1080p, Series S is 900p
One X version at 30fps has "some of the worst framepacing I've seen in a while"
Series S at 60fps "does a poor job at maintaining it"
One X has "seriously degraded texture quality"
Other settings similar across both consoles
18.97 seconds to load in on Series S, 69.55 seconds for One X

Analysis and conclusion
Some games aren't taking full advantage of One X's GPU headroom
Some cross-gen games aren't taking full advantage of the Series S decompression for faster loading
30fps vs 60fps is the norm between crossgen games here
Better CPU and SSD give Series S the advantage
One X is being treaten as an "afterthought" at this point by many devs
One X is getting "left behind"
From the titles tested in the new video, the Series S is clearly better except for arguably Assassin's Creed Mirage
Smaller GPU isn't the issue at this point, it's the One X lacking certain feature sets required for the functionality of current gen games
Series S is a "categorically better experience than the One X in 2024"
 
На консолях все те же проблемы с кадровкой (и на пука тоже):

Shadow of the Erdtree

 
DF считает порт Ace Combat 7 одним из лучших на свитче:


– Change in foliage and grass on Switch with pop in
– Switch also has lighting tweaks
– No screen space reflections on Switch; water surfaces instead reflect a basic impression of the sky color
– However, some may feel that the Switch version actually looks better in this respect
– Lighting quality reduced
– Cockpit view flatter on Switch
– Direct lighting is similar
– Shadow maps seem to have roughly the same resolution in cutscenes and gameplay
– Shadow filtering has a slightly different appearance on Switch
– Cloud simulation is largely intact; similar lighting and structure
– Clouds have more obvious artifacts than Xbox One, but not very noticeable
– Fireballs also look similar
– Motion blue absent on Switch
– Depth of field blur is similar on Switch and Xbox One
– No chromatic aberration
– Switch does a good job with texture quality
– Not much quality lost for CGI scenes
– Ace Combat 7 resolution is 720p when docked
– Switch UI appears to have cleaner UI than Xbox One, possibly 1080p
– 540p in portable mode, but UI is 720p
– Visual settings similar in docked and portable modes
– Targets 30 FPS
– Frame rate is very stable
Нажмите, чтобы раскрыть...
 
Digital Foundry: Black Myth: Wukong - PS5 Tech Review

 
Star Wars Outlaws


 
Warhammer 40K: Space Marine 2 - PS5/Xbox Series X|S/PC Tech Review

 
YT канал ElAnalistaDeBits сравнил новый супер-хит PS - Astro Bot и Super Mario Odyssey на Switch-е, вышедший в 2017 году.
Откуда некоторые черпали идейки в астроботе становится понятно:


https://gamemag.ru/news/189533/astro-bot-vs-super-mario-odyssey-video
 
Насколько же графен в Астроботе круче. Уделали нинку на её же поле детской муйни.))
 
Я в разработке этих игр участия не принимал, если что.:playful:
 
SnV написал(а):
Я в разработке этих игр участия не принимал, если что.:playful:
Нажмите, чтобы раскрыть...
Понятно что по графиту уделали, спиздив идейки и сделав игру через семь лет на в 10 раз более мощном железе )))
Ну игра на самом деле крутая, наверное лучшая у сони в этом году.
 
dimm написал(а):
Понятно что по графиту уделали, спиздив идейки и сделав игру через семь лет на в 10 раз более мощном железе )))
Ну игра на самом деле крутая, наверное лучшая у сони в этом году.
Нажмите, чтобы раскрыть...
Синий напоминает подростка =). Типа такой - это все детская муйня, а вот ТАНЧИКИ!!! Это для взрослых =)))..

В целом, видно, чем вдохновлялись создатели Астробота. И видно, что в плане идей все равно нет такого разнообразия и креатива как в Марево.
 
Только половина из этих идей ещё в марио 64 30 лет назад появилась и с тех пор давно протухла. Астробот хоть какой-то свежей струёй это затхлое болото разбавил. :playful:
 
Indiana Jones and the Great Circle
Одна из самых сильных в графическом плане игр на боксе. Как игра по фильму, так пожалуй лучшая. RT, 60 fps:

 
Делать надо хорошо, а как визуализацию реализовывать - вопрос уже локальный. Оценки пока 9/10 в среднем по больнице.
 
Войдите или зарегистрируйтесь для ответа.
Назад
Сверху