Сравнение мультиплатформенных игр

dimm · 19 июн 2022

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VvuVH4n-sJY&ab_channel=DigitalFoundry

dimm · 29 июн 2022

Sonic Origins

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kas9IbqvJgg

GENERAL

Overall, feels unpolished - glitches and steep price tag make it a tough sell at the moment

The games in the collection are not emulated, but are proper ports remade in the Retro Engine

The frontend for the collection is powered by the Hedgehog Engine

DLC feels tacked on and should have been included

The drop dash (now included in all games) feels glitchy compared to Mania

Classic Mode still uses the Retro Engine versions of the games and doesn't feel entirely faithful

Lots of minor bugs that need to be addressed (Museum typos, Tails getting stuck, Blue Spheres music tempo not increasing, etc.)

VIDEO

All the games are rendered using a bilinear filter rather than a sharp scale, resulting in softened pixels

Turning anti-aliasing on in Origins' settings results in an unacceptably blurry presentation

The other video filter options included with Mania are not present in Origins

PS5/XSX provides a pristine native 4K frontend, Switch is blurrier

Animated videos are incorrectly scaled on the Switch

Anniversary Mode is native 16:9 widescreen, Classic Mode is 4:3

Sonic CD's menu is functionally/visually inconsistent with the other games in the collection

AUDIO

Overall volume levels are too low, especially on the Switch in portable mode

Sonic CD's animated videos are too loud compared to everything else

Several 3&K songs were replaced with versions based on the prototype songs

The music in 3&K is muffled compared to the other games

Sonic CD's music extended music loop sections included in the 2011 version are no longer present

Sonic CD's voice samples are not present

PERFORMANCE

PS5/XSX menus run at 60fps, Switch menus run at 30fps and feels less fluid

The games feature low input lag and feel remarkably responsive

Slowdown eliminated in the games thanks to Retro Engine - games run at a smooth 60fps

Special stages are much smoother compared to the original Genesis/CD versions

Нажмите, чтобы раскрыть...

dimm · 30 июн 2022

Хороший порт Wreckfest на свиче получился:

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iCq-kezIm9k

cars are detailed, reflections are cubemaps

no AA or GI solution

Switch

doesn't stray far from last gen

900p vs 1080 of One

textures take a hit, to the point of ruining some text jokes

alpha grass is gone, trees and shadows simplefied

cars are simpler, geometrically

no motion blur

mostly solid 30fps, replays can drop to 20s

portable mode has teh same settings, 540p scaled to 720p with nearest neighbor

way better than WRC 's port

last gen

settings are all the same, pro and x have further draw distances

XBO/PS4 - 1080p

Pro/X - 1080p, both offer higher res modes

toggle for 4K on One X

PS4 console has to be set to 4K output, then the game renders at a checkerboarded 1800p

lots of artifacts, very ugly

30fps with a couple of drop frames on One with tearing

current gen

color grading is different, colors are cooler, stylistic

foliage is denser and drawn further out

particles added to the dirt effects

bloom lighting added

screen space light shafts

all cars has shadowmaps

big systems are 4K, series s is 1080p

60fps

ps5 is locked

series s drops in replays

series x has drops and tears in gameplay, worse in replays

not technically impressive, but good looking through solid art and direction

worthy successor to Flatout and Test Drive Eve of Destruction

Нажмите, чтобы раскрыть...

dimm · 2 июл 2022

Еще "невозможных" портов на свитч:

View: https://youtu.be/oQQWXHpQPKY

6.4GB vs 21GB on ps4

duplicate data was removed and compression was improved

ps4 is 1080p/30

switch is 918p to 1080p, dynamic

fxaa and motion blur used

devs tried to avoid DRS as much as possible, used for extreme cases

684p - 720p in portable

portable mode was the priority over docked

shadows and ambient occlusion is stripped way down

SSAO is a bit overdone on ps4

lighter, brighter, and lacking depth

aggressive lod

particles and alpha is cut down

the developers avoided blanket drop on texture resolution, lots of strategic cuts

SSR used, which is rare on switch

small bodies like puddles don't have SSR

uses cubemaps for puddles, improved over Sniper Elite 4

80-100 zombies just like ps4, comparable logic

practically locked 30fps, solid frame pacing

among THE BEST switch ports

Нажмите, чтобы раскрыть...

Раскрывают "потанцевал" )))

dimm · 6 июл 2022

View: https://youtu.be/qVdxbaS1BiY

dimm · 7 июл 2022

Сравнение порталов Switch vs Steam Deck vs Xbox 360:

View: https://youtu.be/h7ZzVDahhQU

portal lacks normal maps, specular lighting, and environmental shadow maps
portal 2 uses the updated HL2:E2 which included shadow maps, particles, and hdr lighting
Nvidia's Light Speed Studios worked on the port, they worked on the game prior and did Quake 2 RTX
switch version is identical to the 360 release
360 version runs at 720p with no AA
switch is 1080p with 2x MSAA
720p and 2x MSAA
no AA in Portal 2 in portable mode
ps3/360 was 30fps with frame pacing issues
switch is 60fps with occasional dips
game doesn't like alpha effects or the portals
portals disable motion blur
portable mode clears up the performance issues
the gabe boy can run the games at 1080p with 4x MSAA at 60fps
at 800p, the SD gets 4h of battery life
gamma, texture filtering, and AA are the only differences
OLED is a good selling point of switch over the steam dick
on Series X and One X, the 360 version runs at 4K
Series S, 1440p
xboxes had higher res shadow maps
no xbox has stable 30fps
Switch/SD are the best consoles to play
Нажмите, чтобы раскрыть...

dimm · 14 июл 2022

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vq0qF0JgKXU

has a movie mode, that strips player choice

2.35:1 aspect ratio

digital domain did the motion capture for the game

the facial capture is really well done, but sometimes there are bits of uncanny valley

skin features subsurface scattering and other high quality details

probably some of the best eyes

one of the best character rendering and performances in real-time right now

PS5/Series X - 2160p, dynamic

vertical res is cut down due to black borders

PS5 lowest - 3072x1728

Series X lowest - 3328x1872

lots of post processing masks drops and differences in resolution

Series X has crepuscular rays while ps5 is missing them

might be a glitch as there's no consistency in there appearance or lack there of on ps5

shadows are low res on current gen

much better on PC at highest settings, though the game is demanding at max settings at locked 4k, even for 30fps

3060Ti at max settings and 4k gets 24fps at times

high end consoles are medium/high settings

series s

1621x912 - 2560x1440

textures take a big hit in areas

may be loading, but higher res textures never load in

other cuts include volumetric effects, shadows, and environmental geo

crepuscular rays are more artifacty

all systems have 1-frame drops when camera cuts, not a big issue

PS5 dropped to 27fps in one scene

Series S hits 20-30fps in the prologue opener

after the title card, it's a stable 30

all versions are recommended

Нажмите, чтобы раскрыть...

dimm · 22 июл 2022

STRAY:

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i-Z3_gAs7F4

dimm · 23 июл 2022

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J6JtfGId594

demo is on an i7-7700/3080 with 32GB of ram

new engine

has RT AO

materials and lighting is much better

lots of volumetric effects, particles, and physic

3080 struggled at max settings/4k in the open world

resolution scale at 83% (borderless windowed only so far) stabilizes the framerate at 60fps

settings updates on the fly

low/medium/high RT AO don't have much difference

On vs Off is a very obvious difference

even on low, it's a worthwhile addition

the non-RT setting settings is much more apparent

performance scales equally

shadows below high is a big quality degradation

scene detail below high makes pop in very apparent

SSR - lower than high is a hard sell

could use some RTR

ToD and weather changes the overall quality of visuals, but it's very solid

in this build, there was a crash that reset save file

Нажмите, чтобы раскрыть...

dimm · 3 авг 2022

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s-UpNaAkEvI

made primarily by one person on UE4

pc version uses Nvidia's RiSTIR GI solution RT AO and shadows, consoles do not

RT reflections on consoles and pc

light leaking on console

PC has additional mesh detail

PC has more surfaces and rougher RT reflections than pc

consoles has more foliage in some areas

console has ghosting through it's TAA

best systems order: SX, PS5, SS, Switch

no RT or 120Hz on Series S

RT reflections are low res, but better than SSR due to the many wet surfaces

BVH is missing some objects like particles

SX

dynamic 2160p in default and RT modes

120hz is dynamic 1440p

PS5

dynamic 2160p in both, dips more

120hz drops to around 80% of 1440p

SS

default mode only; around 80-90% of 1440p

Switch

default mode only, 80% of 1080p/720p

minimal dof, lights removed, lower texture quality

no underwater distortion

scene complexity is greatly reduced

lower than low on pc

all systems have adjustable motion blur and fov

performance

SX

default: 60fps with no dips

RT: mainly 60fps with some drops, some segments can cause bigger drops

120hz: mainly 120fps with some drops

PS5

default: similar

RT: similar

120hz: you need to set ps5 to performance mode, outside of the game; can't hold 120hz

SS

default: similar

switch

default: mainly 30, but poor frame pacing

some bugs, like crash to dashboard; some scenes start at 30fps, and need to be reset

impressive work for such a minimal dev team, but also inherits the issues with a minimal dev team aspiring to something greater

2 hours, $20, very fun

don't disable vsync. it's trash

Нажмите, чтобы раскрыть...

dimm · 12 авг 2022

2.9GB on current gen, 5.9GB on last gen

PS+ users who gotten the game on PS4 are not entitled to the PS5 version

PS4/PS4P: dynamic 1080p/30, unstable frametime, 20-30fps

PS5/SX: dynamic 2160p/60

SS: dynamic 1080p/30

settings exactly the same as SX/PS5

pop-in is lessened

vs PC

consoles are softer than maxed out PC

softer shadows than PC, consoles equivalent to high

PC has shorter draw distance

PS5/SX: near perfect 60fps, has some very brief drops of one frame

SS: no drops and evenly framepaced

in some sequences, it runs at a fluid 60fps

PS5 has dualsense adaptive triggers, but not many situations using it

Нажмите, чтобы раскрыть...

dimm · 12 авг 2022

Marvel's Spider Man Remastered PC - DF Tech Review

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xI2VUQsPqJo

reconstruction video coming later

has a launcher upon prior to boot

4:3 support for glorious CRT play

21:9 and 32:9 support

hella cenimatic

has good fov slider

real exclusive fullscreen support

graphic setting changes happen in real time

not many, if any, shader compilation stutters

handled upon first boot, in the menu, and on the fly

cause high CPU load

has very fast boot time, 6.5s from steam menu

config file isn't findable

intro skip button is only on keyboard

load times are good, but slower than ps5

1.92s on ps5, 3.03 on 3.5GB/s pc

cpu doesn't seem to matter

recommended settings (rtx 2060, 1440p)

6GB gpu - high textures

8GB gpu - v.high textures, lower rt

10GB gpu - max it out

SSAO, hbao+ seems to not be working?

dof at medium or high, 1/4 res, same as ps5

low, v.low is 1/8 res

2060 level should use low

hair quality - medium, same as fidelity RT on ps5

no performance rt equivalent

TAA is similar to IQ in PS5, DLSS is the best option if you can use it

shadows on ps5 is close to high

object lod - high setting is ps5 equivalent

crowds/traffic - medium/high are similar to ps5

performance rt has no equivalent

use low traffic, can't see a difference

texture quality - 4x on ps5, use 8x or 16x on pc

ray tracing

high rt resolution (1/2 res)

high rt geo quality

object range is heavy on the cpu

1 kept it above 60fps

6 on R5 3600

the game is cpu-limited

bvh building on the cpu is very heavy

decompression is also handled on the cpu

storage speed isn't even close to a problem

DRS is fine grained in resolution, coarse on ps5

definitely recommended to have on

frametime spikes do happen on low end gpus, even on slightly higher like 2060s

a good port and has better user experience in settings than a great many ports

Нажмите, чтобы раскрыть...

dimm · 20 авг 2022

View: https://youtu.be/-7rpUAaZ048

View: https://twitter.com/noodalls/status/1560062705658384384

View: https://twitter.com/noodalls/status/1560619866385977345

dimm · 22 авг 2022

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cBnvES27Uas

5 settings on SX and PS5

2 at 1080p

2 at 1440p

1 at 2160p

high quality 1440p, ultra high qualith 1080 has RTAO toggle

SS has no modes

RTAO is really good

lighting and volumetric effects is good

more seen in story missions

high vehicle count on all current gen systems allowing for lots of carnage

lots of bugs at varying importance

current gen has half rate npcs

finishing moves look broken with no animation syncing

SSR look low quality/resolution

lots of pop-in, regardless of setting

resolution is fixed in all modes, to its determent

every mode is unlocked

1080p

best for 60fps

ultra with RT is 40-60

ultra is 50-60

max fps is smoothest

all drops during traversal

max fps reduces geometry lod, reduces foliage draw

set pieces also drops fps in max fps mode

1440p

high fps sacrifices geo and draw distance

best balance between performance and IQ

best if you have a VRR display

50-60fps

high quality modes need a 30fps cap

2160p

shadows are lower quality, other settings are dropped down as well

frame rate can drop under 30fps and go up to 40fps

PS5 runs better with RTAO

SX better cpu helps with traversal

in 4K, systems are practically the same

SS

1080p max fps mode

no RTAO

shadow quality is worse

40-50fps, can drop lower

interior areas can be 60fps

all these problems could be fixed with patches. hopefully

Нажмите, чтобы раскрыть...

dimm · 31 авг 2022

Ластовазка на PS5:

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0mv0dAwPqCs

dimm · 3 сен 2022

Нужон-ли был римейк ластоваза?

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5ffCZCcsjvs

dimm · 8 сен 2022

Soul Hackers 2 на Unity оказывается создавался

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KLo6ApqKz9U

dimm · 17 сен 2022

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dMCHwC-oGtI

initial console release on last gen was spotty

cars are high detail but environments are rather low fidelity

premium consoles get new bokeh in menus over gaussian blur on last gen

shadow resolution is high resolution, PS5 has better shadows

Series S has the same settings, but lower quality grass, textures

mirror lighting is different, sometimes too dark to be usable

temporal artifacts in the rain

replays have asset pop-in

Series X is 1440p to 2160p, close to 4K most of the time

PS5 is 1152p to 2160p, around 2160p or 2016p mostly

TAA used but aliasing still shows

Series S is 1080p to 1440p, mostly 1080p

car selection is 4K, but 20fps

PS5 performs best, near locked 60fps

when stressed ~55fps

Series X targets 60 but can drop more than PS5

replays hit the 30s

Series S can get to the 50s in regular races

stressed performs close to X

replays in the 30s

all are better than One X

Series duo loading a 8 secs, PS5 a little worse

Нажмите, чтобы раскрыть...

dimm · 7 окт 2022

А вот и Digital Foundry:

900p and no AA on PS4/XBO
40-60fps typically on old gen systems
textures are greatly degraded
foliage resolution is low, making foliage look sparse
polygonal grass replaced with alpha textured planes
dynamic light sources have been reduced or removed
volumetric effects have been pared back
geometric detail in set dressing is also downgraded
fewer particles
switch looks comparable, artistically
pop-in is the same on old gen and switch
shadow resolution is much lower
no AO on either set of systems
Switch version has AA, not great AA, but has better stability
docked dynamic 1080p, possibly reconstructed
portable dynamic 720p
targets 30fps, stable frame pacing
no motion blur
cutscenes are properly framepaced
further into the game, frame drops become more frequently
big late fights can bring it down to the mid 20s
portable seems to have fewer drops
Нажмите, чтобы раскрыть...

dimm · 11 окт 2022

Войти или зарегистрироваться

Сравнение мультиплатформенных игр

dimm Administrator Команда форума

dimm Administrator Команда форума

dimm Administrator Команда форума

dimm Administrator Команда форума

dimm Administrator Команда форума

dimm Administrator Команда форума

dimm Administrator Команда форума

dimm Administrator Команда форума

dimm Administrator Команда форума

dimm Administrator Команда форума

dimm Administrator Команда форума

dimm Administrator Команда форума

dimm Administrator Команда форума

dimm Administrator Команда форума

dimm Administrator Команда форума

dimm Administrator Команда форума

dimm Administrator Команда форума

dimm Administrator Команда форума

dimm Administrator Команда форума

dimm Administrator Команда форума

Войти или зарегистрироваться

Сравнение мультиплатформенных игр

dimm Administrator Команда форума

dimm Administrator Команда форума

dimm Administrator Команда форума

dimm Administrator Команда форума

dimm Administrator Команда форума

dimm Administrator Команда форума

dimm Administrator Команда форума

dimm Administrator Команда форума

dimm Administrator Команда форума

dimm Administrator Команда форума

dimm Administrator Команда форума

dimm Administrator Команда форума

dimm Administrator Команда форума

dimm Administrator Команда форума

dimm Administrator Команда форума

dimm Administrator Команда форума

dimm Administrator Команда форума

dimm Administrator Команда форума

dimm Administrator Команда форума

dimm Administrator Команда форума

Быстрый поиск